An Oxford Walk and Much More
I wasn’t thinking of having published this in English. I have a draft in another language and considered sending it to a European digital magazine I’ve been in contact with since last summer. But if you are reading this right now, then it means that it went past the review. I am laying here before you what I carry in me insofar as university life and university, as it is, is concerned. So, here go my musings (again).
I was in Oxford last summer. Yes, finally. Before going there, I was trying to finish a novel one of my former students mentioned to me last semester while we co-worked in the CAS garden (Theresa, thank you!). It’s a novel about the arcane history of the Oxford Translator’s Revolution by R.F. Kuang, entitled “Babel.” Somehow, the description in the book of how Oxford gave my visit a little of spatial memory. And while walking through its streets, I found myself slowing down more often (although at some point we had to speed-walk before some colleges closed) than I had intended. There was always something worth another look and a closer look. There were the old college buildings (reliving Harry Potter and Tolkien in Oxford), the stone facades worn by centuries, the libraries whose shelves held the intellectual labors of generations, and the chapels standing quietly amid the movement of students and visitors. And of course, the gargoyles. Yes, gargoyles in Oxford and not in Notre Dame. These were the places that had witnessed extraordinary discoveries, vigorous and rigorous arguments, intellectual rivalries, and the formation of minds and hearts that would eventually influence the world far beyond Oxford.
I wasn’t just impressed by the architecture, though honestly, that always stops me dead. It was how seriously they took learning. Those buildings say: knowledge is worth time. Worth sacrifice. Worth permanence. Talking to a friend whose family members are Oxford alumni and whose mom had helped one college, I realized that, indeed, generations have invested their lives in institutions whose purpose extended beyond the ambitions of any single scholar, much less the head of its Congregation (Oxford’s ultimate legislative body) or the Council (its executive governing body). Yet I wondered what those who established such institutions would make of the way we speak about universities today. Would they recognize our language of international rankings, citation indices, research productivity, employability statistics, and institutional competitiveness? Would they understand the considerable energy we devote to improving our position in global league tables and demonstrating institutional performance? Probably, yes. Probably, not.
I must admit that, yes, it is true that universities have never been free from ambition or rivalry, and there is much to admire in contemporary higher education. Never. Scientific discoveries, technological advances, and expanding educational opportunities are achievements worth celebrating, and are, in fact, being celebrated big time. But surrounded by institutions that have outlived generations of academic careers, I found myself returning to a question: Have we become so concerned with demonstrating how successful our universities are that we have grown less attentive to what their success is ultimately for? And honestly, I won’t deny that it pains me deep down seeing how our world in the academe is becoming more and more a parade of achievements, connections, invitations, and everything else that is quantified and metric-fied (if such a term exists). John Henry Newman, who studied at Trinity College, became a fellow of Oriel, and preached at the University Church of St. Mary the Virgin, confronted a version of this question in The Idea of a University. And I would like to go back to that one passage that deserves particular attention:
“Now, when I say that Knowledge is, not merely a means to something beyond it, or the preliminary of certain arts into which it naturally resolves, but an end sufficient to rest in and to pursue for its own sake, surely I am uttering no paradox, for I am stating what is both intelligible in itself, and has ever been the common judgment of philosophers and the ordinary feeling of mankind.”
He was defending knowledge for its own sake. Not because it gets you a job. Not because it gets you a grant. Because it is good. And that feels urgent now, when we measure a university by its rankings, its publications, its grants, its reputation. The problem isn’t measuring. We have to measure. Excellence needs standards. It needs accountability. It needs honest evaluation. The problem starts when the ruler becomes the reason. When we stop asking “Is this good?” and start asking only “Will this count?”
So for those of us who try to teach with a Christian spirit, and honestly, for those who don’t, Newman pushes us to a harder question: WHAT WOULD IT PROFIT A UNIVERSITY TO WIN EVERY DISTINCTION THE ACADEMIC WORLD CAN OFFER, IF THE PEOPLE INSIDE IT STOP LIVING THE CHARITY THAT GIVES CHRISTIAN EDUCATION ITS MEANING?
When Knowledge Becomes a Means to Recognition
Some people may misunderstand Newman here. I want to emphasize that Newman was not suggesting universities should disregard professional preparation or remain indifferent to society’s needs. His concern, if we truly dig deeper into his thought, was that the value of learning could not be exhausted by its practical rewards. For him, education should cultivate the intellect, enabling students to reason carefully, recognize connections across fields of knowledge, appreciate the limits of their understanding, and develop sound judgment. It should “produce” (I hate that word, “produce,” by the way. As if a student is a product. But you know what I mean.) more than professional competencies or information that can be reproduced in examinations. I recall saying this in the speech I gave to the students last semester during the Equatorial Rites: “A degree may open doors, but what kind of judgment will its holder exercise after walking through them? Expertise may confer authority, but what will that authority serve?”
These questions become uncomfortable when applied to the 21st-century university culture, aren’t they? The QS World University Rankings methodology assigns considerable weight to research and discovery, including academic reputation and citations per faculty member. The Times Higher Education rankings similarly evaluate institutions through indicators covering teaching, research, international outlook, and industry engagement. Such systems provide useful information, encourage improvement, and help students who are entering university compare institutions. Yet they can also create incentives that gradually reshape institutional priorities.
A university may celebrate moving twenty places higher in a ranking. Yet nobody asks whether its students’ intellectual and human experience has improved. Or are they trying to be better persons given their education? A department may increase publication output while becoming less attentive to teaching. An institution may strengthen its international reputation while the people sustaining its daily work become increasingly exhausted or disconnected from one another. These outcomes are not inevitable. Nor are rankings responsible for every institutional difficulty. But the incentives deserve scrutiny when they begin to determine decisions about recruitment, promotion, funding, and academic priorities.
Newman reminds us that knowledge possesses a dignity independent of the recognition it brings. When that distinction disappears, the pursuit of truth can gradually become subordinate to the pursuit of prestige. And I hope we don’t fall into that. I really do.
Publish or Perish: The Human Cost
Few expressions capture contemporary academic pressure more effectively than publish or perish. We repeat it so frequently that we sometimes forget what it reveals about the expectations placed upon scholars and faculty. It is true that publication is indispensable to research, and I acknowledge that. Academics must communicate their findings, submit arguments to scrutiny, and contribute to the development of knowledge. A university that produces little serious scholarship cannot invoke Newman’s defense of learning as an excuse for intellectual inactivity. Yet publication pressure can distort the very activity it is intended to encourage.
A 2024 study in Research Evaluation, drawing on survey data from academics in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, found that researchers experiencing greater pressure to publish were more likely to prioritize journal reputation and publication speed when selecting publication outlets. Sounds familiar, doesn’t it? A survey of more than 1,600 biomedical researchers, discussed in Nature in January 2025, found that nearly three-quarters believed science was experiencing a reproducibility crisis, with pressure to publish identified as the leading perceived cause. These were researchers’ perceptions rather than proof of causation, but they raise serious questions about academic incentives. And, of course, the human consequences deserve equal attention. A study involving 676 postdoctoral researchers at nine Dutch universities found that approximately 40 percent reported serious mental-health difficulties, with publication and grant pressures, career uncertainty, and work–life imbalance among the identified stressors.
Behind these figures are persons who entered academic life with intellectual curiosity and the desire to contribute something worthwhile. Yes, they are persons and not machines. Consider a lecturer who spends an afternoon helping a struggling student understand a difficult subject, knowing that those hours could have been devoted to completing a manuscript. Or a researcher who patiently mentors a younger colleague or student without expecting recognition. These contributions sustain university life. And it barely shows in performance evaluations. Sometimes it even looks like slacking off because they simply don’t see you in your own cubicle. You’re with a student.
DORA, the San Francisco Declaration on Research Assessment, has been saying this for years: judge research by its merit, not by the journal’s brand. Using the organization’s own words, we might as well consider these:
the need to eliminate the use of journal-based metrics, such as Journal Impact Factors, in funding, appointment, and promotion considerations;
the need to assess research on its own merits rather than on the basis of the journal in which the research is published; and
the need to capitalize on the opportunities provided by online publication (such as relaxing unnecessary limits on the number of words, figures, and references in articles, and exploring new indicators of significance and impact)
We should encourage academics to publish important work and recognize exceptional scholarship. But we should also acknowledge the teacher who accompanies students with patience, the researcher who shares knowledge generously, and the administrator whose fairness and justice, rooted in true charity, strengthen the institution. These are not alternatives to excellence. They belong to a fuller understanding of it.
The Education My Mother Wanted for Us
Before I encountered Newman or began thinking seriously about the purpose of a university, my mother had already taught us something about education that has remained with me throughout my life. Growing up, my siblings and I heard her repeat a particular reminder so often that I can still remember its words and the seriousness with which she said them. She wanted us to study well, work hard, and make something worthwhile of our opportunities. But she was even more concerned about the kind of people we would become along the way. She reminded us to act uprightly, to be honest and to treat others with genuine charity, even and especially when nobody was watching and there was no possibility of receiving recognition. What mattered was not simply how we behaved in public, when our actions might be noticed or praised, but how we conducted ourselves when we had nothing to gain and nobody to impress.
And then came a warning that I must have heard a thousand times, expressed with that unmistakable mixture of affection and maternal authority:
“I hope that one day you won’t add anything more to your last name. I don’t want people to know you as so-and-so, the unjust; so-and-so, the uncharitable; so-and-so, the deceiver; or so-and-so, the lazy.” (These words were said in the vernacular my mother speaks. I won’t translate the tone because you had to be there.)
She was not speaking about academic titles or professional qualifications. She certainly wanted us to earn through honest work. She was speaking about the other titles we acquire through our conduct, the descriptions people eventually attach to our names because of the way we treat them.
It is a familiar occurrence. Unfortunately, we know someone who may spend years earning degrees, distinctions, and professional recognition, only to become known among colleagues as dishonest, arrogant, unjust, or incapable of kindness. My mother wanted us to understand that a good name was not simply something inherited from our family. It was something we had a responsibility to preserve through our choices, especially those made when no one was looking. And while she valued education deeply, she never allowed us to imagine that academic achievement could compensate for a lack of character. Not while she lives.
I have returned to that lesson many times in university life, where qualifications, academic appointments and professional distinctions naturally occupy a prominent place. We devote years to acquiring letters that may eventually appear before or after our names, and we are understandably pleased when our work receives recognition. Yet I wonder whether we give sufficient attention to the less formal descriptions our daily conduct may be adding to those same names. Reputations can be mistaken or unfair, and we should be cautious about judging people through labels. But my mother’s warning concerned something deeper than reputation: the character we form through repeated choices, whether or not anyone notices them (as already mentioned above). At the time, my mother hadn’t read Newman’s insistence that knowledge has value beyond its immediate usefulness, but she still reminded us that intellectual accomplishment does not excuse failures of character. Her concern was not whether we would become successful people, although she certainly hoped we would. She wanted us to become people whose success would not come at the expense of others, whose competence would be accompanied by integrity and whose education would make us more capable of doing and being good.
Her lesson was simple: Whatever titles you eventually earn, be careful about the ones your conduct adds to your name.
What Would It Profit a University?
Newman was careful not to confuse intellectual cultivation with moral goodness. In the preface to The Idea of a University, he distinguished the intellectual purpose of university education from moral and religious formation. He understood that a person could possess considerable knowledge without necessarily becoming virtuous. This distinction strengthens his argument especially if education does not automatically produce goodness, those of us involved in university life must take seriously the responsibility of ensuring that intellectual achievement does not become detached from the moral demands of our relationships. For universities with a Christian formation, this responsibility is particularly “demandingly” obligatory. And expected.
St. Josemaría Escrivá, whose vision inspired the founding of the University of Navarre and many academic initiatives, connected professional competence with service to others. In Conversations with Monsignor Escrivá de Balaguer, he emphasized the responsibility of universities to prepare students for a life of Christian charity and generous service to their neighbors. If you go back to the text, you will see that he did not regard charity as a substitute for competence. Rather, he expected serious study, professional excellence, and work carried out with care. But he understood that knowledge should place us in a better position to serve others, rather than merely increasing our personal influence or prestige.
This brings me to a question drawn from the Gospel: “For what does it profit a man, to gain the whole world and forfeit his life?” (Mark 8:36) Now let me translate that for our context: What would it profit a university to gain the highest rankings, attract international recognition, publish in prestigious journals and secure substantial research funding, if the people within it do not live charity to its fullest demands? What would it profit us to speak eloquently about human dignity in our classrooms while failing to respect it in our offices, meetings and corridors? These questions concern everyone involved in university life. Charity is tested in how we respond to a struggling student, the patience we show a colleague who has made a mistake, the fairness with which we exercise authority, and our willingness to acknowledge contributions that may never receive public recognition.
Charity does not mean abandoning standards or avoiding difficult decisions. Not at all. It requires us to exercise judgment without humiliating others, correct mistakes without contempt, and recognize that people possess dignity beyond their academic performance or professional usefulness (this we know too well in the Philosophical Anthropology class we offer our students).
On 22 October 2026, Pope Leo XIV spoke to the International Congress on Pastoral Care in Schools and Universities about students who walk through educational institutions feeling anonymous. And I just want to zero in on the Pope’s emphasis on the importance of communities where someone remembers a student’s name, notices an absence, and rejoices at a return. And these gestures rarely appear in institutional rankings, but they reveal the quality of the relationships through which education takes place. A university’s identity cannot be confined to its chapel, religious activities, marketing materials, or mission statement. It must also be visible in how its members treat one another, especially when charity requires patience, sacrifice, and the willingness to put another person’s needs before personal convenience.
Excellence Without Losing Our Purpose
I do not want these reflections to be understood as an argument against ambition. Far from it. I want our universities to be excellent. I also want to encourage demanding research, celebrate discoveries, reward exceptional teaching, and pursue international recognition when it reflects genuine academic achievement. Students deserve serious intellectual formation, and society has every reason to expect universities to use their resources responsibly. A university that neglects academic standards cannot compensate for that failure by invoking charity. Good intentions are not substitutes for competent teaching, rigorous scholarship, or responsible administration. But neither should academic excellence become an excuse for neglecting the human responsibilities that accompany it. Try reading Oxford College testimonials to see the humanity behind success.
In his homily for the inauguration of the academic year of the Pontifical Universities on 8 October 2026, which I was graced to be part of, Pope Leo XIV urged us, students, teachers and researchers, to remember the deeper purpose of our intellectual work. His appeal to “guard your hearts” warned against allowing ambition, rivalry, and routine to obscure the motivations that first drew people into academic life. And he’s right. The loss of purpose rarely happens suddenly. It develops through small compromises and shifting priorities, until the desire to contribute meaningfully becomes entangled with the need for recognition.
So, I keep these three men together in mind.
Newman reminds us that knowledge is worthy of pursuit for its own sake. St Josemaría reminds us that professional competence carries responsibilities towards others. Pope Leo XIV invites us to examine whether our intellectual ambitions remain connected to the human and Christian purposes that give them meaning. Together, these perspectives call us to pursue excellence without allowing success to become our ultimate measure of worth.
What Will Remain?
As I kept walking through Oxford, I thought about the generations who had passed through its colleges and libraries. Some became distinguished scholars, scientists, writers and public figures. Most have disappeared from public memory. Their academic appointments, professional distinctions and personal ambitions have long since been overtaken by time. Yet something of their influence may remain in the people they taught, the questions they encouraged, the knowledge they shared and the generosity with which they exercised their responsibilities. I think that we will continue to measure research outputs, evaluate teaching, compare institutions and celebrate academic success.
We should do these things well, with honesty and a proper understanding of their limitations. But I hope we never become so absorbed in achieving the highest rankings, publishing in prestigious journals or strengthening our institutional reputation that we forget the people with whom we share the daily work of university life. The moment we do, I’m afraid that we have lost the essence of a university and its search for truth.
I return, finally, to my mother’s words, which have followed me from childhood into the world of universities, academic qualifications and professional responsibilities. She is certainly pleased to see us acquire degrees, pursue our careers, and make worthwhile contributions to society. But I know that none of these achievements would have impressed her very much if they came at the expense of honesty, justice or charity. She was teaching us to be careful about what we allowed our conduct to add to our names.
And so, when I think about the university and the education we ought to pursue, I find myself asking a question that is both institutional and deeply personal. What would it profit a university to gain the highest rankings, the most prestigious distinctions and the admiration of the academic world, if the people within it failed to live the charity they profess? What would it profit any of us to acquire the finest titles before or after our names, only to have our conduct attach to them descriptions that no education should ever make us proud to bear? Newman reminds us that knowledge is worthy of pursuit for its own sake. My mother taught me that the worth of our education must also be visible in the kind of people we become. I hope that our universities will be remembered for both their intellectual achievements and the humanity of the people who made those achievements possible. A university is rightly called an institution for higher learning. Yes, you heard me right: higher learning. And also, yes, a university is not a place for higher ranking but for higher learning (if you need me to repeat it). Maybe we can reconsider the other side of examination administered to students. Why not also indulge in a sort of “self-examination” so that we are better at it, too.
For what would it profit us to gain the whole academic world, if, along the way, we were to lose the charity that should give our work its deepest meaning?




